跳到正文
BMJ· Blanco·· 8 天前

Beyond checklists: journals need to rethink how they implement reporting guidelines

Beyond checklists: journals need to rethink how they implement reporting guidelines

原文摘要

出版方登记 · OpenAlex

Reporting guidelines are sets of recommendations and guidance for authors on how to report their research.Their aim is to improve the completeness and transparency of published research and, ultimately, its reproducibility and usability.Journals increasingly require authors to follow reporting guidelines and submit completed checklists alongside their manuscripts, yet poorly reported research is common. 1 Journals need to consider how they can better support authors to use reporting guidelines effectively.We discussed this issue repeatedly with the late statistician Doug Altman.In 2018, together we published a scoping review of interventions to improve adherence to reporting guidelines. 2 Journals requiring authors to submit a completed checklist was one of the most common approaches, but we found no evidence that it improved the completeness of reporting of published articles.Our own research made us increasingly sceptical that the problem could be solved simply by requiring more checklists to be completed.We found frequent discrepancies between what authors reported in submitted checklists and what appeared in their published papers.3 Other research, including a randomised trial, also questioned whether this approach improves reporting.

页面未能读取全文,以上为出版方登记的摘要;方法与图表见原文

来源:BMJ · doi.org